MACP on Hierarchy: Supreme Court dismissed the Govt. petitions against HC Decision
MINISTERIAL STAFF ASSOCIATION, SURVEY OF INDIA
Dear Comrade,
The Principal CAT [OA 904/2012 dt. 26-11-2012], Delhi and the Punjab & Haryana High Court [CWP No. 19387 of 2011 (O&M) Date of Decision: 19.10.2011] have held that MACP is to be granted on promotional hierarchy and not on next higher Grade Pay as per the 6th Pay Commission Recommendation. The SLP filed by Union of India against the P&H decision was dismissed by the Supreme Court [CC 7467/2013].
Punjab & Haryana High Court [CWP No. 19387 of 2011 (O&M) Date of Decision: 19.10.2011]
The Principal CAT [OA 904/2012 dt. 26-11-2012], Delhi
Dear Comrade,
The Principal CAT [OA 904/2012 dt. 26-11-2012], Delhi and the Punjab & Haryana High Court [CWP No. 19387 of 2011 (O&M) Date of Decision: 19.10.2011] have held that MACP is to be granted on promotional hierarchy and not on next higher Grade Pay as per the 6th Pay Commission Recommendation. The SLP filed by Union of India against the P&H decision was dismissed by the Supreme Court [CC 7467/2013].
Yours Comradely,
Manoj Kumar Sharma
Secretary General
Ministerial Staff Association
C/o-Northern Printing Group
Survey of India
Supreme Court [CC 7467/2013].
Punjab & Haryana High Court [CWP No. 19387 of 2011 (O&M) Date of Decision: 19.10.2011]
The Principal CAT [OA 904/2012 dt. 26-11-2012], Delhi
Appended copies of the Court Orders are not readable. Can you post legible copies for our reading
ReplyDeleteNeedful done please click on the images
DeleteCongrats for your great effort. You gave a platform to unite and walk holding eachothers hands for a nice day ahead.
ReplyDeleteIf anyone has taken the benefit of the outcome decision of CAT,
ReplyDeleteHigh-court, then please share here.
Is this verdict applicable for all govt. servants... AKK
ReplyDeleteThe verdict of Apex Court should change the policy to help for those who are suffering from grade pay hierarchy. One should not happy with the mere outcome of the verdict. We should strive hard to make DOPT (which is the nodal agency for MACP) to issue necessary guidelines to this effect.
ReplyDeleteWhen will the Government issue DOPT Orders to implement MACP on Promotional Hierarchy and why is there such a inordinate delay in issuing the DOPT
DeleteWhen will the Government issue the DOPT Order to implement MACP on Promotional Hierarchy as against the Grade Pay Hierarchy and why is that the Central Federation not initiating any kind of strong protest.
DeleteHail the verdict.
ReplyDeleteIt is certain, DoPT will implement and bring out necessary orders for all departments.
I've sent the appeal with CAT, High Court, supreme court's order to Sri Raghavaihya, GS/NFIR, & Sri S.G.Mishra, GS/AIRF on 13.09.2013. And friends both the General Secretaries took steps immediately and wrote letter on 13 & 14.09.2013 to Railway Board for implementing the same on basis of Supreme Courts order with arrears.
ReplyDeleteWhat the finance department,6th finance commission, JCA, MACP Anomaly committee etc could not understand for last five years are made to under stand the natural justice by High Court and Supreme Court. Really there exists court in India and so we employees are saved. Thanks to Courts for upholding the justice given to the Govt. employees.
ReplyDeletevery nice and apt comment to the Govt. of India.
DeleteGovt. employees have to fight to get their share of rights implemented, thereby getting demotivated and dejected.
This verdict should be honoured by all Central Govt Departments and be implemeneted without waiting for the DOPT to issue orders in true spirit.
ReplyDeleteUnless DOPT issues suitable orders based on the Apex Court Orders, no Department will implement the same.
ReplyDeletewhen the dopt issue the orders b cauz 7th cpc also on the way and most important is if loksabha election date is announce then again dopt delayed to issue the order
ReplyDeletewho not DOPT implementing Suprem court verdict of promotional hierarchy to LDC/UDC, must be given immedialy. HC Tiwari, Lucknow
ReplyDeleteGrate efforts for getting decision from the CAT and High Court and also Supreme Court decision of dismissal of SLP. Now we are waiting for the DOPT order for implementation of the order of CAT and High Court. Sanjay Kapoor, ASI, Agra
ReplyDeleteThere should not be any more delay in implementing Supreme Court Order of MACP. Let us hope that DoPT will issue orders shortly
ReplyDeleteHonrable Supreme courts Verdict on Promotional Hierarchy shouldbe implemented immediately.
ReplyDeleteIs there any possibility for contempt of court?
ReplyDeleteCourt orders on many such beneficial issues are still pending with concerned Department in Government of India for implementation. Therefore, the need of the hour is to give maximum publicity to the subject matter and apex court verdict through news papers and visual media so that the entire affected employees in the country would be aware the same so that they can also individuals write to DOPT for early issue of matching Govt orders for implementation of MACP on hierarchical posts. Govt would also try to procrastinate/delay the matter (especially during the present occasion as General Election is coming up during 2014) and try to pass on the buck to the successive Govt which in turn will result in further delays. We must try to get the formal Govt orders issued during the UPA Government itself.
ReplyDeleteAs per the Supreme Court Verdict, the DoPT may please take up the issue of MACP for LDC & UDC must be on Promotional hierarchy basis. I am also one of the victim of MACP on hierarchy basis, as I got 1st financial upgradation under MACP grade from Rs.1900 to 2000 (only Rs.100 benefit for 10 years of regular service in LDC Cadre which is discouraging and heartburning issue) after adapting the MACP scheme from 1.9.2008, whereas my colleagues LDCs who got CAS before 1.9.2008 are in GP of Rs.2400/-. I pray to the DoPT / Ministry of Expenditure to kindly re-issue the guidelines in light of the Supreme Court Orders for granting of MACP for LDCx & UDCs on Promotional Hierarchy not on Grade Pay Hierarchy please.
ReplyDeleteWhen the higher cadre employees and staff nurse employees only raise their demands the DOPT issues clarifications/upgradation etc. etc. immediately. But, when it is the issues of LDC/UDC, even after the order of Hon'ble Supreme Court, it is being delayed by DOPT to issue an order. Just imagine what a very strong racket is working against the LDC/UDC.
ReplyDeleteThis is the reason again we filed a new petition in Hon'ble CAT Kolkata for granting MACP in Promotional Hierarchy. I would like to request everyone to file such type of Case in CAT.
ReplyDeleteThis is the reason again we filed a new petition in Hon'ble CAT Kolkata for granting MACP in Promotional Hierarchy. I would like to request everyone to file such type of Case in CAT.
ReplyDeleteI am agreed too that everyone to file such type of case in CAT.
ReplyDeleteI thing all LDC & UDC of central govt employees should fight unitedly against this unjustified govt policy.
ReplyDeleteDOPT should issue a general order on this matter addressed to all Mins. of GOI at the earliest please.
ReplyDeleteWhy the DOPT is not taking the decision to issue the common order to all Ministries even though the H'ble Supreme Court has dismissed the SLP filed by the Govt. against the H'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court order to Grant the MACP on Promotional Hierarchy. My doubt is whether the Govt. has filed any suit in this matter or why the Govt/DOPT is delaying to issue the common order. The Govt./DOPT should inform that is there any another appellate authority is in our nation after getting the order from the H'ble Supreme Court. I request all the LDC/UDC/eligible employees and those who are suffered a lot and loss of financial benefits after implementation of MACP, kindly send their representation to Prime Minister along with the copies of H'ble CAT/High Court/Supreme Court orders copies.
ReplyDeletelekin sarkar is kab tak implement karegi.is bare men employees unions kya kar rahi hai? unions ko iske liye andolan karna chahiye.sarkar supreme court ke adesh ke bad bhi adesh jari nahi kar rahi hai iske kya karan hai.hamare netaon ko iske bare men dekhna chahiye.kyonki employees unke uper bharosa karme unhe apana representative chunte hai,Do something concrete.
ReplyDeleteBut the DoPT has not yet published orders in this respect.
ReplyDeleteHow long the DoPT will take to issue amendment orders.
आखिर सरकार या वित्त मंत्रालय इस आदेश को क्रियान्वित करने के लिए आदेश क्यों नहीं जारी कर रही हैं । क्या ये माननीय सुप्रीमकोर्ट और अन्य कोर्टों की अवहेलना नहीं मानी जाएगी
ReplyDeleteI, on behalf of my all colleagues very grateful to the Government, Hon'ble Court and all authorities for their GREAT DECESION.
ReplyDeleteBUT C DICISION IS ONLY REGARDING DELAY. DUE TO THIS STATE CAN NOT FORCED TO IMPEMENTED THEM.
ReplyDeleteSir we are the people neck moment of retirement and eagerly awaiting for the great Honorable D opt orders on Hierarchy based MACP and it will benefit the so many employees B K RAMANJANAPPA BANGALORE
ReplyDeleteGreat that DOPT or any relevent authority to execute orders, does not care even for Hon'able High Court / Supreme Court Verdicts ref. MACP in Promotional Hierarchy, almost six months gone.
ReplyDeleteWhy did DOPT delay in this particular case and not delaying in subsequent cases? An appeal has already been filed in th next case (Sanjay Kumar)
ReplyDeleteDOPT should issue order in favour of financial upgradation in promotional hierarchy in MACP Scheme to avoid future court cases in different hon'ble courts. kpsingh, president, central govt. library association , dehradun
ReplyDeletethanx for sharing info. about it.
ReplyDeleteSupreme Court Advocate
Why, DOPT has not issued the order till date after suprim court judgement on MACP.
ReplyDeleteAfter Supreme Court dismissed the SLP of DoPT. Delhi CAT has passed order dated 12.03.14 and High court Upheld the order of CAT Delhi in order dated 14.07.2014. Even then DoPT is not convinced.
ReplyDeleteCan anybody give details of above Supreme Court's order or link thereof?
ReplyDeleteGovt. of India is compelling the aggrieved employees to approach ho,ble courts in different parts of India for MACP in promotional hierarchy . kpsingh dehradun
ReplyDeletePeople who have joined later to me have got change in grade pay on macp policy. is it justified. is there any orders relating this. Can I approach court inthis regard.
ReplyDeletesrivatsa
What is the present status of macp on promotional hierarchy. Govt keep silent on this . Pl do the needful
ReplyDelete